Originally posted by: Moranis
Date: February 13, 2009 at 04:37 PM
Source: https://forum.mmajunkie.com/threads/alistairs-contract-situation.10489/
bjj_rage said:
Moranis said:
reborn fighting mid-level fighters at best. Overeem isn't drastically better now than he was 2 years ago when Shogun dominated him or 16 months ago when Sergei Kharitonov knocked him out, he just isn't. Since his loss to Sergei he has beaten Paul Buentello, Tae Hyun Lee, Mark Hunt (by submission), and Gary Goodridge with the no contest with Mirko mixed in. I'm sorry, but any credible HW would have beaten those guys rather handidly.
Overeem is not a top ten HW until he actually beats top ten HW's.
Click to expand...
dude, you keep on coming with the shogun crap... and now sergei? what's wrong with loosing to sergei? he's a beast. Anyway, you are partly right, Those names arent very impressive, though the way he beat them was. By the way I will throw that k-1 kick *** beating he put on Hari there two... I think that was really impressive.
Click to expand...
He lost to Sergei got knocked out by essentially one punch and that was 16 months ago. And yes Sergei is a good fighter, but at that time he was at best at the back end of the top ten. So in conclusion in the last two years; Overeem has lost to a LHW in Shogun, lost to a borderline top ten HW in Kharitonov, beaten two cans in Michael Knapp and Tae Hyun Lee, beaten a washed up Gary Goodridge, beaten a mediocre MMA in Hunt, and beaten a mediocre Paul Buentello. Throw in the no contest with Mirko, a fight he probably would have won had he not cheated multiple times. And while his KO of Badi Hari is impressive, it was K-1 rules and is not a MMA fight.
I'm sorry the love affair with Overeem is blown way out of propotion. He is an average at best fighter and poses no real threat to any top HW. In fact the only top ten level MMA fighters he has beaten were Sergei Kharitonov in 2006 and Igor Vovchanchyn in 2005 (at the tail end of Igor's magnificent career). He beat Roman Zentsov in 2002 which is a credible win though neither was all that great back then. Hunt and Buentello are credible wins as well. He has a couple of solid wins at LHW over Belfort (twice). That's it. His overall record is 29-11 and those are the only seven credible victories of the entire 29 wins. The 11 losses are pretty much against every other good opponent he fought.
Overeem is a fairly exciting fighter and he would add some quality depth to the UFC or Affliction, but I can't see him challenging any of the top guys in either promotion. He just isn't that good.