POLL: Best 3 or Best 4?

3 best or 4 best

  • Total voters
    15
Eranys said:
I actually like Trig's idea a lot more. This adds a layer of strategy. I say the captains should pick.
Click to expand...
I just think the way we’ve got it now is best. You select 4 players, one sucks that week it’s not fair on the other 3. I know everyone would be in the same boat blah blah, but this is a team event. This game has notable weight missers, most times it can be laziness, or people that don’t give a fuck etc, and other times shit happens where life can get in the way, so why should the ffers that never, ever miss weight get punished for other people’s misfortunes that week? This is why we have teams where one can slot in or the top 4 get the highest scores. Why do we need to make this more complicated idk?

^And fuuuck you @Trig for making me write all that shit!
 
MMAFTM13 said:
You select 4 players, one sucks that week it’s not fair on the other 3.
Click to expand...
Yeah, man. That's how sports and games work sometimes. I like.this idea because it adds an actual element of strategy that was missing before. Right now, this is just piggybacking off of another game with no real control. This adds an easy to use lever to make things more interesting. And the captains will start out picking the same names, but even the best players have off weeks, and the player picks will get more attention as the game progresses.

But, really gentlemen, how can we even discuss this any further until @HKOG gives us his esteemed thoughts and analysis?
 
I had a thought about the game yesterday! I said it's up to the team to be sure that all players have made their picks. I realized that there's no way for them to know who made their picks. I'll create a new routine in the app so every time a player make his picks, all members on his team will receive an email saying something like "CoreyMB" has made his picks. So, everyone will know who's MIA.
 
Eranys said:
I actually like Trig's idea a lot more. This adds a layer of strategy. I say the captains should pick.
Click to expand...
don't work for my team, Xammie will be benched every week.
 
Eranys said:
Yeah, man. That's how sports and games work sometimes. I like.this idea because it adds an actual element of strategy that was missing before. Right now, this is just piggybacking off of another game with no real control. This adds an easy to use lever to make things more interesting. And the captains will start out picking the same names, but even the best players have off weeks, and the player picks will get more attention as the game progresses.

But, really gentlemen, how can we even discuss this any further until @HKOG gives us his esteemed thoughts and analysis?
Click to expand...
Nah, this is how team events always have been.


For instance, All team mates make weight, but the 5th person could end up with the highest score and it means nothing. That's stupid.. I'm out if that's how it is.

If anything I should be supportive of this as I ain't got a problem not being picked due to weight issues but this ruins team events for me.
 
Nastycrow said:
I had a thought about the game yesterday! I said it's up to the team to be sure that all players have made their picks. I realized that there's no way for them to know who made their picks. I'll create a new routine in the app so every time a player make his picks, all members on his team will receive an email saying something like "CoreyMB" has made his picks. So, everyone will know who's MIA.
Click to expand...
I have always made my picks on Sat morning unless it's a china card or something. I don't need nobody bird-dogging me via email to make my picks. Even though I quit every week, I've never missed weight.
 
coreymb said:
Nah, this is how team events always have been.


For instance, All team mates make weight, but the 5th person could end up with the highest score and it means nothing. That's stupid.. I'm out if that's how it is.

If anything I should be supportive of this as I ain't got a problem not being picked due to weight issues but this ruins team events for me.
Click to expand...
Jeez, ok, calm down, Fight Magnet. Don't hit me again.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top