Book Reviews

Wuthering Heights, Emily Bronte. A gothic novel written in 1847 but set around 1800 in the Yorkshire moors of England. It tells the tale of two small but well-off families which appear to be entirely made up of horrible people. The main antagonist, Heathcliff, was found as a homeless child and taken in by one of the families, but his mistreatment by them while growing up warps him into a serial schemer and abuser as an adult, and most of the book is him inflicting his vitriol on everyone around him. Undeniably beautifully written, but I had a bit of trouble relating to why everyone in the book was so utterly hateful. I thought it might be because naturally I would have trouble relating to rich English people living in the countryside two hundred years ago, but it looks like contemporary reviewers also struggled with the relentless bleakness. One example:

"How a human being could have attempted such a book as the present without committing suicide before he had finished a dozen chapters, is a mystery. It is a compound of vulgar depravity and unnatural horrors."

Seems a bit strong (suicide?) but you get the point.
 
Wuthering Heights, Emily Bronte.
The Brontës grew up reading Romantic literature--the novels of Sir Walter Scott, the poetry of Lord Byron. This shaped their view of the world. Because this was their formative literary milieu, and especially for Emily, the sibling who ventured least from the family home, and spent the most time on their native moorlands, we see a novel almost untouched by the contemporary Victorian zeitgeist. Heathcliff and Cathy are figures of high Romance--not in the hearts and flowers sense, but in the Romantic Period sense--the celebration of nature, the belief in the supernatural, the privileging of emotion over reason. The term soulmate dates to this period. When Cathy says "I am Heathcliff," she is aserting that they two are one and the same.

It isn't surpising that the novel met with such a strong reaction. It was born into the Victorian Era, a time of restraint and decorum. Brontë's novel was simply too dark, too passionate, too wild for the times.
 
The Brontës grew up reading Romantic literature--the novels of Sir Walter Scott, the poetry of Lord Byron. This shaped their view of the world. Because this was their formative literary milieu, and especially for Emily, the sibling who ventured least from the family home, and spent the most time on their native moorlands, we see a novel almost untouched by the contemporary Victorian zeitgeist. Heathcliff and Cathy are figures of high Romance--not in the hearts and flowers sense, but in the Romantic Period sense--the celebration of nature, the belief in the supernatural, the privileging of emotion over reason. The term soulmate dates to this period. When Cathy says "I am Heathcliff," she is aserting that they two are one and the same.

It isn't surpising that the novel met with such a strong reaction. It was born into the Victorian Era, a time of restraint and decorum. Brontë's novel was simply too dark, too passionate, too wild for the times.
Wuthering Heights is additionally of its time and author for two reasons that come to mind. One, the Heathcliff/Cathy attraction is comparable to the bad boy/good girl today and ever; bad boy treatment and behaviour, for some sheltered or damaged females, is compelling, even as it is destructive and belittling. Two, being cruel was, not unlike as presented in Dangerous Liaisons, in that era a kind of game, a frivolity, a popular diversion and a personality accepted, if not appreciated.
 
License to Pawn: Deals, Steals and My Life and Gold & Silver, Rick Harrison. Known from the everlasting series Pawn Stars, this is main character Rick's autobiography, written during the peak of the show maybe 15 years ago or so. Starts with his childhood (in this part of the book he really overplays the whole trope about "I underachieved and was a fuck-up but only because I'm such a genius I was bored with everything"), goes into the early years as his father (the Old Man) starts various trading businesses, which eventually became their now-famous pawn shop. Rick had the idea for a reality show and shopped it around, filmed a failed pilot for HBO, until finally getting a hit on the History channel that would go on for about 650 episodes now. It was pretty interesting, but then again I'm a casual fan of the show, so someone unfamiliar probably would not be interested.

Alexander the Great, Philip Freeman. Alexander is a polarizing historical figure, depending on who is doing the writing he was either a military genius or a bloodthirsty drunken youth; possibly both. Upon the death of his father, he became king of Macedonia around 330 BCE at the age of just 20, which was then just one of many local and unremarkable provinces of Greece. He goes about conquering all of Greece and then sets his sights on the mighty Persian empire to the east, invading and conquering until his empire stretched from Greece to India to Egypt. Freeman has a great writing style for this sort of thing, turning it into a narrative rather than a list of events. He also acknowledges the many different accounts of some of the events, and how they are perceived through history, in my opinion doing his best to present a balanced accounting of this extraordinary man.
 
military genius or a bloodthirsty drunken youth; possibly both.
Most definitely both - he was like the Jon Jones of classical general world. Absolutely brilliant tactician and strategist, who was also blessed with perfect timing for an invasion of Persia.

I've had that book on my list for a while now.
 
RAVEN 23 by Gina Keating

It's telling that the word Blackwater is nowhere in this title. In 2007, social media was the new way to besmirch reputations, control the narrative, bend lazy minds your direction, and turn complicated situations into a single divisive word.

Paul Slough, Dustin Heard, Evan Liberty and Nick Slatten, aka "Raven 23," learned this lesson when they were deployed by the state department (as back-up for Raven 4, currently in Baghdad to protect diplomat Redeina Fattah) after a car bomb explosion in Nisour Square in Baghdad.

Along with Raven 22, Raven 23 were made aware that a white Kia sedan in that area possibly contained another explosive device. As Raven 23 entered the square, the soldiers (call them mercenaries, former marines, because words matter), heard the sounds made by AK-47's, used by insurgents, and as they were fired up on, a white Kia sedan drove toward them, not responding to any repeated rules of engagement orders to stop. Being the follow (last) vehicle, they were their own last line of defense, and fired in the direction of the AK's and ultimately the Kia.

In the debriefings that followed, all involved agreed that front turret gunner of Raven 23, Jeremy Ridgeway, had fired "hundreds" of rounds into the crowd, even when repeatedly told to "cease fire!" Additionally, backed up by ordnance, the number of 8 killed was confirmed. How that number increased to double then triple that number is the story of CYA that is not exclusive to the military.

Stories were altered, deals were made, rules were bent, Jeremy Ridgeway turned states evidence against his four marine friends, and all 4 above mentioned men were sentenced to life in separate Federal Prisons.
(Years later, they were all pardoned by the President).

Machiavelli said, "never fight from aggression, when you can fight by deception."

If you think you know the whole story, read the facts.
 
Love the Jon Jones comparison! More MMA tie-ins in book reviews, please.
It came to me in the last moment before posting and was edited in. I thought it was a great analogy. Alexander once impulsively killed a close friend and top general in a drunken rage. If Jon Jones was an ancient King leading an army, I could easily see him doing the same. They were both incredibly badass warriors who found no equal on the battlefield. They both drank excessively and had a hard time getting out of their own way. And they were both truly great and legendary in their own way.
 
I WHO HAVE NEVER KNOWN MEN by Jacqueline Harpman

This slim tome was sent to me by a friend in Sweden, and it is translated into English from the original French by a Swedish woman, which may be relevant to someone, so I added this.



Of varying ages, a group of 40 women are imprisoned in a cage sunk deep into the ground, guarded always by armed guards. The youngest is simply called the child, the fortieth person is unknown, and is the narrator. Excepting the child, the women know how they came to be in the cage, but will not tell the child, who becomes rebellious and tries, unsuccessfully, to seduce the youngest guard.

One day an alarm goes off, and a pounding of Corcorans followed by silence confirms that the women, locked securely, are alone with no access to food or water. Eventually they manage to escape. As a group, they wander the inhospitable badlands, seeking sustenance and society.

Over the years, they discover several more sunken cages, each one full of dead prisoners. Their numbers decline via death by age, disease, infirmity, refusal to keep moving onward.

No other living humans or creatures are ever found and the final survivor, the narrator, dies.

This book, 200 pages, compelled me to read it in one sitting, to the detriment of my scheduled appointments. The precis makes it sound dreary and repetitive, perhaps, but that is what I found so intriguing--though not in those words.

This book made me think about the following, which is brilliant for fiction. Recommend.

What role does society play in our lives, and do we truly mean it when we say we would be happiest away from everyone? Why are the women caged? Why won't any of them tell the narrator or child what happened prior? Are they on earth? Where did the guards go? Why didn't any of the other prisoners manage to escape--did they die or were they killed? What makes one person keep searching, and another give up? What is the human spirit without humanity?
 
Amazon had a collection of short kindle books available for free (called the Forward collection), by very well-known and successful authors, all on the subject of rapidly developing technology and the future:

Summer Frost, Blake Crouch (Wrote Wayward Pines, Dark Matter, etc.) A timely story about a tech company racing headlong toward developing an AI superintelligence, exploring the risks as the AI rapidly outpaces the ability of the human overseers to keep up. Seems not particularly original, but of course Crouch throws in some twists and good, fast-paced writing to make this quite worthwhile.

Emergency Skin, N.K. Jeminson (won an unheard of three consecutive Hugos for her Broken Earth trilogy). Earth was apparently wiped out by environmental disasters long ago, and one of the off-planet colonies is planning a one-man return trip to Earth to pick up some sort of MacGuffin or other (cell samples or something), and the visitor does not discover what he expects. A good story, but being Jemison, she can’t resist throwing in a hodge podge of woke lectures is a very short story. What’s bad and resulted in the destruction of earth? The usual suspects: white people, men, countries having borders, individual property ownership, and capitalists. The solution? Why, of course, communism, especially given its unblemished track record of success, lol.

The Last Conversation, Paul Tremblay (wrote the book that Knock at the Cabin was based on, and I’ll be checking out his Head Full of Ghosts soon). Starts out pretty stock; dude wakes up in a room, no idea who he was and how he got there. A handler eventually starts communicating with him via speaker, as he eventually learns more and more about his circumstances, and it ain’t great.

Randomize, Andy Weir (The Martian, Project Hail Mary). What would happen if quantum computing and qbit entanglement concepts were combined with a casino heist story? Andy Weir has the answer in this story.

You Have Arrived at Your Destination, Amor Towles (A Gentleman in Moscow). This one tackles the subject of genetic engineering using an analogy with credit scores. Credit scores successfully predict a person’s likelihood to repay a loan by gathering various personal and financial characteristics and throwing them against a massive database of other people with similar characteristics and how successful people in that cohort have been paying back loans. What if we could do the same thing with life? Learn everything you can about the parents, run it against similar situations and see how things turned out for kids in the past in this cohort, then then engage in some futuristic genetic engineering to “nudge” things in the right direction.

Ark, Veronica Roth (Divergent series). The world is ending (again). The planet has already been evacuated of most people, except for the last few scientists at the Svalbard Global Seed Vault (a real place) in Norway, inventorying the last few plant species they want to take with them on the final ship out of town. Not much happens other than that; lots of introspection and a few flashbacks.

Good collection overall. Easy reads, interesting concepts.
 
Amazon had a collection of short kindle books available for free (called the Forward collection), by very well-known and successful authors, all on the subject of rapidly developing technology and the future:

Summer Frost, Blake Crouch (Wrote Wayward Pines, Dark Matter, etc.) A timely story about a tech company racing headlong toward developing an AI superintelligence, exploring the risks as the AI rapidly outpaces the ability of the human overseers to keep up. Seems not particularly original, but of course Crouch throws in some twists and good, fast-paced writing to make this quite worthwhile.

Emergency Skin, N.K. Jeminson (won an unheard of three consecutive Hugos for her Broken Earth trilogy). Earth was apparently wiped out by environmental disasters long ago, and one of the off-planet colonies is planning a one-man return trip to Earth to pick up some sort of MacGuffin or other (cell samples or something), and the visitor does not discover what he expects. A good story, but being Jemison, she can’t resist throwing in a hodge podge of woke lectures is a very short story. What’s bad and resulted in the destruction of earth? The usual suspects: white people, men, countries having borders, individual property ownership, and capitalists. The solution? Why, of course, communism, especially given its unblemished track record of success, lol.

The Last Conversation, Paul Tremblay (wrote the book that Knock at the Cabin was based on, and I’ll be checking out his Head Full of Ghosts soon). Starts out pretty stock; dude wakes up in a room, no idea who he was and how he got there. A handler eventually starts communicating with him via speaker, as he eventually learns more and more about his circumstances, and it ain’t great.

Randomize, Andy Weir (The Martian, Project Hail Mary). What would happen if quantum computing and qbit entanglement concepts were combined with a casino heist story? Andy Weir has the answer in this story.

You Have Arrived at Your Destination, Amor Towles (A Gentleman in Moscow). This one tackles the subject of genetic engineering using an analogy with credit scores. Credit scores successfully predict a person’s likelihood to repay a loan by gathering various personal and financial characteristics and throwing them against a massive database of other people with similar characteristics and how successful people in that cohort have been paying back loans. What if we could do the same thing with life? Learn everything you can about the parents, run it against similar situations and see how things turned out for kids in the past in this cohort, then then engage in some futuristic genetic engineering to “nudge” things in the right direction.

Ark, Veronica Roth (Divergent series). The world is ending (again). The planet has already been evacuated of most people, except for the last few scientists at the Svalbard Global Seed Vault (a real place) in Norway, inventorying the last few plant species they want to take with them on the final ship out of town. Not much happens other than that; lots of introspection and a few flashbacks.

Good collection overall. Easy reads, interesting concepts.
...and my "to read" pile just became taller. These all sound solid. Thank you.
 
Back
Top